nav emailalert searchbtn searchbox tablepage yinyongbenwen piczone journalimg journalInfo journalinfonormal searchdiv searchzone qikanlogo popupnotification paper paperNew
2025, 02, v.55 323-333
组合导航系统故障诊断和隔离算法研究综述
基金项目(Foundation): 湖南省自然科学基金(2022JJ30669); 湖南省科技创新计划资助项目(2021RC3073)~~
邮箱(Email):
DOI:
发布时间: 2024-06-21
出版时间: 2024-06-21
网络发布时间: 2024-06-21
移动端阅读
摘要:

组合导航系统故障诊断和隔离算法对于增强系统可靠性和安全准确的导航至关重要。综述了近年来国内外组合导航系统故障诊断和隔离算法领域的研究进展。介绍了包括基于残差统计、模型架构以及数据驱动的故障检测算法和不同数据融合结构下的故障隔离容错算法。分析了现有算法的性能和应用范围,并梳理了发展脉络以及面临的困难挑战。对算法的发展趋势进行了展望,为提高组合导航系统可靠性研究提供了思路。

Abstract:

The fault detection and isolation of integrated navigation systems is crucial for enhancing system reliability and ensuring safe and accurate navigation. A comprehensive review of the recent advancements in fault detection and isolation algorithms for domestic and foreign integrated navigation systems is provided. Various fault detection methods, including residual-based statistical approaches, model-based techniques, and data-driven algorithms are discussed. Additionally, fault isolation algorithms that leverage different data fusion structures are discussed. The strengths and limitations of existing fault detection and isolation algorithms are analyzed and the challenges and difficulties faced in their development are highlighted. The development trend of the algorithm is prospected, and the ideas for improving the reliability of integrated navigation systems are provided.

参考文献

[1]唐璐杨,唐小妹,李柏渝,等.多源融合导航系统的融合算法综述[J].全球定位系统,2018,43(3):39-44.

[2]孙学磊,赵忠,夏家和.基于滤波残差的组合导航系统故障检测研究[J].计测技术,2009,29(2):5-7.

[3]刘子龙,楼家祺.基于正交性原理的组合导航系统故障检测[J].控制工程,2024,31(10):1841-1848.

[4]徐峰,阎磊,傅金琳.一种改进的残差χ2故障检测算法[J].舰船科学技术,2022,44(13):144-148.

[5] ZHANG C,ZHAO X B,PANG C L,et al. Improved Fault Detection Method Based on Robust Estimation and Sliding Window Test for INS/GNSS Integration[J]. Journal of Navigation,2020,73(4):776-796.

[6]吕旭,胡柏青,戴永彬,等.基于AR建模的组合导航系统渐变故障双阈值检测方法[J].中国惯性技术学报,2021,29(1):133-140.

[7]韩斌子,胡柏青.基于时间序列建模的组合导航系统故障诊断[J].哈尔滨工程大学学报,2018,39(11):1843-1847.

[8] JIN X Q,ZHANG X Y,LI S P,et al. Detection of Slowly Varying Spoofing Using Weighted Kalman Gain in GNSS/INS Tightly Coupled Systems[J]. GPS Solutions,2024,28(1):1-13.

[9]郭鑫,刘小雄,何启志,等.基于UKF的水下航行器IMU故障检测与诊断方法研究[J].计算机测量与控制,2019,27(8):30-34.

[10]张浩,肖勇,杨朝旭,等.基于双状态卡方故障检测的组合导航系统[J].航空学报,2020,41(增刊2):53-60.

[11]杨春,张磊,郭健,等.采用双状态传播卡方检验和模糊自适应滤波的容错组合导航算法[J].控制理论与应用,2016,33(4):500-511.

[12]周朋进,吕志伟,丛佃伟,等.基于双状态χ2检测和快速强跟踪AUKF的组合导航算法[J].中国惯性技术学报,2019,27(6):771-777.

[13]张捷,薄煜明.基于时延补偿卡尔曼滤波器的NCS组合式χ2故障检测[J].系统仿真学报,2009,21(18):5869-5873.

[14]张华强,李东兴,张国强.混合χ2检测法在组合导航系统故障检测中的应用[J].中国惯性技术学报,2016,24(5):696-700.

[15] GENG K K,CHULIN N A. Applications of Multi-height Sensors Data Fusion and Fault-tolerant Kalman Filter in Integrated Navigation System of UAV[J]. Procedia Com-puter Science,2017,103:231-238.

[16]高广乐,高社生,彭旭,等.渐消SPRT在SINS/CNS/SRS导航系统软故障诊断中的应用[J].中国惯性技术学报,2020,28(6):834-840.

[17]李振威,程咏梅,刘刚,等. INS/ADS/GPS组合导航高灵敏度故障检测和识别方法[J].中国惯性技术学报,2020,28(5):694-700.

[18]杨镜,华冰,熊智.多源导航系统软、硬故障检测新方法研究[J].压电与声光,2013,35(5):647-652.

[19]高超,赵修斌,庞春雷,等.一种残差χ2与改进SPRT互辅的故障检测方法[J].火力与指挥控制,2020,45(4):148-152.

[20] WANG R,XIONG Z,LIU J Y,et al. Chi-square and SPRT Combined Fault Detection for Multisensor Navigation[J].IEEE Transactions on Aerospace and Electronic Systems,2016,52(3):1352-1365.

[21]李杰,陈安升,陈帅,等.多源组合导航系统故障检测技术研究[J].导弹与航天运载技术,2020(3):86-91.

[22]高超,赵修斌,庞春雷,等.基于衰减记忆思想的故障容错方法[J].测绘通报,2019(5):93-97.

[23]张闯,赵修斌,庞春雷,等.基于改进型AIME-RCTM的组合导航联合故障检测方法[C]∥第九届中国卫星导航学术年会.哈尔滨:[出版者不详],2018:174-179.

[24] YE Q W, GU Y, LI L, et al. Integrity Monitoring for GNSS/INS Integrated Navigation Based on Improved AIME[C]∥China Satellite Navigation Conference. Jinan:Springer,2023:533-544.

[25]李臻,宋丹,张鹏飞,等.基于抗差扩展卡尔曼滤波和外推-积累的RAIM方法[J].系统工程与电子技术,2017,39(9):2094-2099.

[26] WANG S Z,ZHAN X Q,PAN W C. GNSS/INS Tightly Coupling System Integrity Monitoring by Robust Estima-tion[J]. Journal of Aeronautics, Astronautics and Avia-tion,2018,50(1):61-80.

[27]任利简,赵修斌,庞春雷,等.基于抗差估计改进的GNSS/INS组合导航完好性监测方法[J].航天控制,2021,39(5):21-26.

[28]姜颖颖,潘树国,叶飞,等.基于抗差估计和改进AIME的缓变故障检测方法[J].系统工程与电子技术,2022,44(9):2894-2902.

[29]刘士明,李四海,郑江涛,等.基于预滤波器和两级AIME的GNSS/INS超紧组合慢变故障检测[J].航空学报,2022,43(3):415-425.

[30]熊琤.基于关联规则模型的导航卫星故障诊断方法[J].计算机光盘软件与应用,2014,17(19):103-105.

[31]张鑫鑫,王冲,徐晔,等.基于领域知识图谱的卫星故障辅助诊断与处置方法[J].上海航天(中英文),2023,40(3):151-158.

[32] DING D F,ZHAO X M. Navigation System Failure Detec-tion Based on FM Gauss Wavelet Transforms[J]. Applied Mechanics and Materials, 2014, 3365(602-605):1874-1878.

[33] ZHOU F N, PARK J H, LIU Y J. Differential Feature Based Hierarchical PCA Fault Detection Method for Dy-namic Fault[J]. Neurocomputing,2016,202:27-35.

[34] DAI Y T,LAI J Z,ZHANG Q Q,et al. An Improved Fault Detection and Isolation Method for Airborne Inertial Navi-gation System/Attitude and Heading Reference System Redundant System[J]. Aerospace,2023,10(12):1024.

[35] MENG X L,WANG H,LIU B B. A Robust Vehicle Loca-lization Approach Based on GNSS/IMU/DMI/Li DAR Sensor Fusion for Autonomous Vehicles[J]. Sensors,2017,17(9):2140.

[36] JURADO J,RAQUET J,SCHUBERT K C M,et al Resi-dual-based Multi-filter Methodology for All-source Fault Detection,Exclusion, and Performance Monitoring[J].Navigation,2020,67(3):493-510.

[37] GUO M Z,GUO C,ZHANG C. Hi/H∞-optimised Fault Detection for a Surface Vessel Integrated Navigation Sys-tem[J]. Journal of Navigation,2022,75(3):554-571.

[38] GIPSON J S,LEISHMAN R C. A Framework for Collabo-rative All-source Navigation with Fault Detection and Ex-clusion[J]. IEEE Transactions on Aerospace and Elec-tronic Systems,2022,58(5):4615-4625.

[39]刘路,史贤俊.基于模型与数据驱动的自适应模糊规则故障诊断方法[J].海军航空大学学报,2023,38(4):368-374.

[40] ZHONG L N,LIU J Y,LI R B,et al. Approach for Detec-ting Soft Faults in GPS/INS Integrated Navigation Based on LS-SVM and AIME[J]. Journal of Navigation,2017,70(3):561-579.

[41]张闯,赵修斌,庞春雷,等. LS-SVM辅助的小幅值及缓变故障检测与容错方法[J].中国惯性技术学报,2019,27(3):415-420.

[42]郝顺义,夏奇,黄国荣,等.局部加权的LS-SVM大气数据组合导航故障检测[J].空军工程大学学报(自然科学版),2015,16(2):5-9.

[43]戴海发,卞鸿巍,马恒,等.基于一类SVM的综合导航系统信息故障检测方法[J].中国惯性技术学报,2017,25(4):555-560.

[44] YANG H H,MENG C,WANG C. A Hybrid Data-driven Fault Detection Strategy with Application to Navigation Sensors[J]. Measurement and Control,2020,53(7-8):1404-1415.

[45]张涛,徐晓苏.基于C-SVM的组合导航系统故障诊断算法[J].中国惯性技术学报,2011,19(2):239-242.

[46] WANG Y Y, SUN R, CHENG Q, et al. Measurement Quality Control Aided Multisensor System for Improved Vehicle Navigation in Urban Areas[J]. IEEE Transac-tions on Industrial Electronics,2024,71(6):6407-6417.

[47]柳敏,赖际舟,刘建业,等.基于SVR的惯性/卫星组合导航系统故障诊断方法[J].控制与决策,2016,31(10):1889-1893.

[48]戴海发,卞鸿巍,马恒,等.基于SVR的导航传感器自适应野值检测方法[J].导航定位与授时,2020,7(5):141-146.

[49] HA Y M,ZHANG H. Fast Multi-output Relevance Vector Regression[J]. Economic Modelling,2019,81:217-230.

[50]赵博,王天宇,张润峰.基于模糊相关向量机的UUV中缓变故障检测方法[J].计算机与数字工程,2023,51(4):838-844.

[51] JARADAT M A,ABDEL-HAFEZ M F,SAADEDDIN K,et al. Intelligent Fault Detection and Fusion for INS/GPS Navigation System[C]∥2013 9th International Symposi-um on Mechatronics and Its Applications(ISMA). Am-man:IEEE,2013:1-5.

[52] SUN R,CHENG Q,WANG G Y,et al. A Novel Online Data-driven Algorithm for Detecting UAV Navigation Sen-sor Faults[J]. Sensors,2017,17(10):2243.

[53]徐博,李盛新,王连钊,等.基于ANFIS的多AUV协同定位系统量测异常检测方法[J].自动化学报,2023,49(9):1951-1966.

[54] ZHANG Q,WANG X Y,XIAO X,et al. Design of a Fault Detection and Diagnose System for Intelligent Unmanned Aerial Vehicle Navigation System[J]. Proceedings of the In-stitution of Mechanical Engineers,Part C:Journal of Mecha-nical Engineering Science,2019,233(6):2170-2176.

[55]刘军坡,吴兆麟,曹玉墀,等.基于卷积神经网络的智能船舶组合导航系统故障检测算法[J].舰船科学技术,2023,45(2):155-158.

[56] XU H W,LIAN B W. Fault Detection for Multi-source In-tegrated Navigation System Using Fully Convolutional Neural Network[J]. IET Radar, Sonar&Navigation,2018,12(7):774-782.

[57] ALEKSANDRǎS′,KRZYSZTOF K. Homogeneous Ensem-ble Model Built from Artificial Neural Networks for Fault Detection in Navigation Systems[J]. Journal of Computa-tional and Applied Mathematics,2023,432:115279.

[58]赵修斌,高超,庞春雷,等. BP神经网络辅助的缓变故障双阈值检测法[J].控制与决策, 2020, 35(6):1384-1390.

[59]王兵.基于自适应神经网络的组合导航故障诊断技术研究[J].现代电子技术,2015,38(23):122-126.

[60] JI Y L,WU F L,ZHANG Y C,et al. An INS Fault Diagno-sis Method Based on State Chi-square Test and Optimized GA-BP Neural Network[J]. Lecture Notes in Electrical Engineering,2022,644:871-882.

[61] LIU P F,ZHANG W. A Fault Diagnosis Intelligent Algo-rithm Based on Improved BP Neural Network[J]. Interna-tional Journal of Pattern Recognition and Artificial Intelli-gence,2019,33(9):1959028.

[62]刘东涛.基于改进决策树的导航系统故障诊断的研究[J].现代导航,2022,13(5):334-338.

[63] NING Y P,WANG J,HAN H Z,et al. An Optimal Radial Basis Function Neural Network Enhanced Adaptive Ro-bust Kalman Filter for GNSS/INS Integrated Systems in Complex Urban Areas[J]. Sensors,2018,18(9):3091.

[64]周坤芳,占太阳.基于RBF网络故障检测的多系统组合定位研究[J].现代导航,2012,3(6):407-410.

[65]陈光武,程鉴皓,杨菊花,等.基于改进神经网络增强自适应UKF的组合导航系统[J].电子与信息学报,2019,41(7):1766-1773.

[66]龚文龙,周凌柯,鲜委,等.基于EM算法的组合导航系统容错方法[J].电光与控制,2023,30(9):74-78.

[67]罗治斌,刘永峰,宋欣.基于滑窗自适应的故障估计与补偿及其在组合导航系统中的应用[J].无人系统技术,2022,5(4):63-74.

[68] ZHANG X, HE B, GAO S, et al. Multiple Model AUV Navigation Methodology with Adaptivity and Robustness[J]. Ocean Engineering,2022,254:111258.

[69] ZHAO L,KANG Y Y,CHENG J H,et al. A Fault-tolerant Polar Grid SINS/DVL/USBL Integrated Navigation Algo-rithm Based on the Centralized Filter and Relative Posi-tion Measurement[J]. Sensors,2019,19(18):3899.

[70]唐泽亮,吴永明,抗电磁干扰的无人机GPS/INS组合导航方法[J].机械设计与制造,2019(4):260-263.

[71]王东宇,张慧君,李孝辉,等.遮挡环境下的基于AKF组合导航定位方法研究[J].电子测量与仪器学报,2023,37(5):171-179.

[72] LIU W,SHI Y H,HU Y,et al. An Improved GNSS/INS Navigation Method Based on Cubature Kalman Filter for Occluded Environment[J]. Measurement Science and Technology,2022,34(3):035107.

[73]张一康,陈燚涛,刘芳.基于自适应卡尔曼滤波的RFID/SINS组合导航研究[J].无线电工程,2024,54(1):98-104.

[74] TSENG C H,LIN S F,JWO D J. Fuzzy Adaptive Cubature Kalman Filter for Integrated Navigation Systems[J]. Sen-sors,2016,16(8):1167.

[75]荆蕾,孙炜玮,潘新龙,等.测量噪声方差未知的多传感器组合导航集中融合算法[J].电子测量与仪器学报,2023,37(10):164-171.

[76] XU B,GUO Y,HU J M. An Improved Robust Kalman Fil-ter for SINS/DVL Tightly Integrated Navigation System[J]. IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measure-ment,2021,70:1-15.

[77] XU B, GUO Y, JIANG Z H, et al. An Invariant Error-based SINS/DVL/USBL Tightly Coupled Integrated Navi-gation Algorithm and Its Robust State Estimator[J].Ocean Engineering,2024,292:116511.

[78] HASHEMI M,SHAMI E. New Fault Detection and Fault-tolerant Scheme for Doppler Velocity Logger Outage in O-cean Navigation Systems[J]. Journal of Navigation,2021,74(2):409-424.

[79]孙传波,王虹,杨然,等.基于单类支持向量机的组合导航容错算法[J].电光与控制,2024,31(5):30-33.

[80]张静娴,杨英东,钱峰.基于卡尔曼滤波-神经网络预测的GNSS/INS误差反馈校正的研究[J].电子设计工程,2015,23(10):103-105.

[81] NIU X J,DAI Y H,LIU T Y,et al. Feature-based GNSS Positioning Error Consistency Optimization for GNSS/INS Integrated System[J]. GPS Solutions,2023,27(2):89.

[82]李云飞,李广飞,杨勇,等.基于量子遗传算法的RBF神经网络智能滤波组合导航算法[J].云南大学学报(自然科学版),2019,41(增刊1):21-26.

[83]韩崇昭,朱洪艳,段战胜.多源信息融合[M]. 3版.北京:清华大学出版社,2022.

[84]张崇猛,王戈,舒东亮,等.自适应滤波的舰船综合导航系统信息融合技术[J].火力与指挥控制,2012,37(7):39-42.

[85]方峥,熊智,华冰,等.基于滤波方差阵修正的非等间隔联邦滤波算法[J].压电与声光,2014,36(2):241-247.

[86]赵海飞,陈帅,刘清秀,等.多传感器异步信息多源组合导航算法实现[J].导航与控制,2022,21(1):41-48.

[87] JIAO Z. Research on Asynchronous Registration Method Based on Improved Unequal-interval Federated Filter[C]∥2019 IEEE 3rd Information Technology, Networking,Electronic and Automation Control Conference. Chengdu:IEEE,2019:2320-2323.

[88]耿峰,祝小平,周洲.一种有效的组合导航容错滤波技术研究[J].西北工业大学学报,2016,34(3):449-455.

[89] YAO L H,LI M,XU T H,et al. GNSS/UWB/INS In-door and Outdoor Seamless Positioning Algorithm Based on Federal Filtering[J]. Measurement Science and Technology,2023,35(1):015135.

[90] YUE Z,LIAN B W,TANG K C,et al. A Novel Adap-tive Federated Filter for GNSS/INS/VO Integrated Navigation System[J]. Measurement Science and Tech-nology,2020,31(8):85102.

[91] GAO Y,GAO Z H,ZONG H,et al. Adaptive Weighted Federated Kalman Filtering Based on Mahalanobis Dis-tance and Its Application in Navigation[J]. IET Com-munications,2023,17(17):1962-1973.

[92] SHI W C,XU J N,HE H Y,et al. Fault-tolerant SINS/HSB/DVL Underwater Integrated Navigation System Based on Variational Bayesian Robust Adaptive Kalman Filter and Adaptive Information Sharing Factor[J].Measurement,2022,196:111225.

[93] CAO S Y,GAO H L,YI Y. Adaptive In-flight Alignment Method for SINS/GPS/Polarization Integrated Naviga-tion System Based on the Degree of Observability Analy-sis[J]. IEEE Sensors Journal,2023,23(15):16699-16709.

[94]吴永亮,蔡亚男,宝音贺西,等.临近空间无人飞行器多余度容错导航系统设计[J].航空学报,2016,37(增刊1):91-98.

[95]桑可可,祖家奎,叶晓宇,等.无人机多源冗余传感器容错估计算法研究[J].机械与电子,2024,42(1):47-52.

[96]景羿铭,王融,熊智,等.空天飞行器多源多余度模糊容错导航系统设计方法[J].兵工学报,2020,41(4):670-680.

[97]程鉴皓,李荣冰,刘刚,等.基于集值决策的机载冗余惯导系统状态判决方法[J].中国惯性技术学报,2022,30(4):553-560.

[98] KANG J,XIONG Z,WANG R,et al. Resilient Multi-source Integrated Navigation Method for Aerospace Ve-hicles Based on On-line Evaluation of Redundant Infor-mation[J]. Aerospace,2022,9(7):333.

[99]孙涛,郑辛,常琦,等.基于因子图的状态估计方法运算实时性研究[J].导航定位与授时,2022,9(5):126-135.

[100]徐昊玮,廉保旺,刘尚波.基于滑动窗迭代最大后验估计的多源组合导航因子图融合算法[J].兵工学报,2019,40(4):807-819.

[101]叶彦斐,史永翔,刘帅.基于因子图消元优化的多传感器融合定位算法[J].国外电子测量技术,2022,41(6):1-7.

[102]袁国帅,齐咏生,刘利强,等.一种基于因子图消元优化的激光雷达视觉惯性融合SLAM方法[J].电子学报,2023,51(11):3042-3052.

[103]戴海发,卞鸿巍,马恒,等.基于因子图的鲁棒性增量平滑算法的水面无人艇组合导航方法[J].中国惯性技术学报,2018,26(6):778-786.

[104]左思琪,朱建良,沈凯,等.基于可观测度分析和增量因子图的多源融合导航方法[J].导航定位与授时,2020,7(6):22-29.

[105] DAI J,LIU S L,HAO X Y,et al. UAV Localization Algo-rithm Based on Factor Graph Optimization in Complex Scenes[J]. Sensors,2022,22(15):5862.

[106] MA X S,LIU X X,LI C L,et al. A Post-processing Algo-rithm Based on Factor Graph Optimization for Autono-mous Underwater Vehicle Integrated Navigation[J].Transactions of the Institute of Measurement and Con-trol,2023,45(4):595-607.

[107] YU C H, CHAO Z C, XIE H R, et al. An Enhanced Multi-sensor Simultaneous Localization and Mapping(SLAM)Framework with Coarse-to-fine Loop Closure Detection Based on a Tightly Coupled Error State Itera-tive Kalman Filter[J]. Robotics,2023,13(1):2.

[108] PELLETIER J R,O'NEILL B W,LEONARD J J,et al.AUV-assisted Diver Navigation[J]. IEEE Robotics and Automation Letters,2022,7(4):10208-10215.

[109]栾啸飞,张华强,李孝旭,等.基于RFR辅助的因子图组合导航算法[J].电光与控制,2023,30(6):69-73.

[110]杨然,王虹,孙传波,等.基于因子图优化的DBSCAN聚类组合导航算法[J].微波学报,2023,39(增刊1):409-413.

[111]孙克诚,曾庆化,王守一,等.基于因子图导航的伪距故障检测与自适应隔离方法[J].中国惯性技术学报,2022,30(1):65-73.

[112]戴海发,卞鸿巍,杜红松,等.基于自适应因子图优化的导航系统信息融合方法[J].中国惯性技术学报,2023,31(1):45-52.

[113]吴坤,刘海颖,谢阳光,等.基于因子图的GNSS鲁棒优化算法分析[J].航空科学技术,2021,32(4):73-78.

基本信息:

中图分类号:TN967.2

引用信息:

[1]庾靖,李蓬蓬,魏征,等.组合导航系统故障诊断和隔离算法研究综述[J].无线电工程,2025,55(02):323-333.

基金信息:

湖南省自然科学基金(2022JJ30669); 湖南省科技创新计划资助项目(2021RC3073)~~

发布时间:

2024-06-21

出版时间:

2024-06-21

网络发布时间:

2024-06-21

检 索 高级检索